Small business blog · October 8, 2026

What plumbing and HVAC shops learned from their own numbers

Independent stories first, then the vendor ones, clearly labeled. The pattern is the same: one honest look at your own records, reviewed on a schedule.

Most success stories in the trades are written by the software company that sold the software. Nothing wrong with that, as long as you read them that way. So we went looking for plumbing and HVAC stories from people with nothing to sell, then read the vendor stories with that bar in mind.

Here's what we found, independent sources first.

A Montana plumber gets a financial checkup

Action Plumbing Plus is a plumbing company in Great Falls, Montana. According to a success story from the Montana small business development center (SBDC), its staff grew from five to 12 during 2019.1 That's an older story, and the SBDC is promoting its own counseling program, but it's a government source with a named company and real before and after figures.

The starting point was a historical financial analysis by the regional director, Jason Nitschke. It showed big swings in the company's performance, and the books were in a spot where borrowing wasn't an option. The owner's daughter, Kayla Weiss, had become business manager in 2018.1

The story names no software. The SBDC logged 27 meetings, over 21 hours of counseling and a January 2019 workshop, all aimed at cash position, liquidity, efficiency and profit. They used the Work Opportunity Tax Credit to hire and set an employee retention policy.1

The SBDC reports that between 2017 and year end 2019, gross profit increased by 147 percent, net profit by 150 percent and wages paid by 36 percent. By December 2019 the company was solvent and had secured funding to buy a building, putting in 25 percent equity.1 Weiss put it simply: "We finally have positive equity in our business."1

Two HVAC contractors and their maintenance agreements

In July 2023, ACHR News talked to contractors about maintenance agreements.2 Two of them are worth a close look.

Vassar Service of Richmond is in Mechanicsville, Virginia. Owner Cliff Dennis told ACHR News they previously weren't collecting enough data. About four years before the article, after roughly four months of weekly training with the National Comfort Institute, they switched to what NCI calls high-performance agreements. Techs now take measurements on every visit: testing before and after the work, checking blower wheels and compressors, looking for refrigerant leaks.2

The switch changed the price. The article puts the older visit at $60 to $80 and the new one at around $225. Dennis said most customers pick the upgraded visit when it's shown next to the basic $59 service.2

DiFilippo Service Co. in Paoli, Pennsylvania, has approximately 1,600 maintenance agreements, and Vince DiFilippo told ACHR News the company has an annual renewal rate of 83%. Techs book the next visit about six months out so the office can staff the calendar. Members get 20% off parts and labor, priority service and a monthly payment option.2

Renewal rate and price are half the picture. The other half is what each agreement costs you to service. The fictional heating and plumbing company in our demo, Bramblewick, built on synthetic data, asks exactly that: "Which memberships are losing us money?" Member perks plus a few slow tune-ups can turn an agreement upside down without anyone noticing.

What the software companies report

The next three are vendor marketing. Each one bundles new software with new habits, so treat the numbers as what the vendor reports.

Adaptive Climates is a commercial HVAC company in Toronto, so it's Canadian, with 14 technicians and four office staff. In a customer story published by ServiceTrade, the software they bought, the company had been running on spreadsheets, handwritten work orders and manual billing, with invoices months behind the work.3

ServiceTrade's story says that once finished jobs flowed straight to invoices, the company uncovered $200,000 in previously unbilled work within four months, and invoices that once lagged two to three months now go out the same week the job is done.3 No one at the company is named as the source of those figures. We wrote more about this kind of leak in finished work that never got invoiced.

Fluid Plumbing, Electrical & Air Conditioning is Australian. In a ServiceTitan blog post from June 2026, the weekly performance report was compiled by hand and took six to eight hours, and owner David Mikkelsen said that data was always a week old. It became an automated nightly report.4 Leads had been split evenly across technicians, though Mikkelsen pointed to techs averaging a $5,000 ticket next to others at $1,000. Now the high-value jobs go to the top performers. The post says revenue per active truck per day rose two-and-a-half times after going live, a figure it doesn't attribute to anyone.4

Inception Plumbing appears in an undated customer story from Plecto, a dashboard company. The location isn't given. Their field software lumped every technician into one blended number, and the CFO, Lindsey Ramsey, was pulling reports by hand and tracking the week on a whiteboard with colored highlighters.5 They split conversion rate and average sale by call type (drain, plumbing service, water heater) and ranked techs for dispatch. Plecto reports conversion went from 68% to the mid-70s about a month later. One month is a short window, but the idea holds up.5

Lessons for your shop

Electrical contractors have similar stories, collected in our electrical post, and landscapers, roofers and pest control companies show up in the home services roundup.

Sources

  1. Montana Department of Commerce, Great Falls Regional SBDC, "Action Plumbing Plus Inc." success story (undated, 2019 success stories). Government. commerce.mt.gov
  2. The ACHR News, "Contractors Share Maintenance Agreement Best Practices" (July 18, 2023). Trade press. achrnews.com
  3. ServiceTrade, Adaptive Climates customer case study (February 17, 2026). Vendor marketing. servicetrade.com
  4. ServiceTitan blog, "Fluid Plumbing Needed Live Data to Grow. With ServiceTitan, Record Months Are Piling Up" (June 25, 2026). Vendor marketing. servicetitan.com
  5. Plecto, "How Inception Plumbing Achieved 100% Conversion Days Using Plecto" (undated). Vendor marketing. plecto.com

What would you ask your own records?

Send us the one question you can't answer today, in your own words. We'll talk through whether the records you already keep can answer it. The Tiber River Business Data Platform is accepting design partners, and you can click around the live demo with a fictional company first.

Email Josh your question

Or write to josh@tiberriverconsulting.com

← All small business posts