Ask an owner how the business is doing and you'll often get a feeling, or a screen with twenty numbers on it. Neither one tells you what to fix on Monday. The companies below did better with one number, picked on purpose and looked at on a schedule.
Three landscapers, three numbers
Back in 2015, Landscape Management magazine profiled three landscaping companies that each picked one key number and tracked it hard.1 It's an older story, but the habit hasn't aged.
LegacyScapes in Groveland, Florida, was struggling with profitability on some jobs, and change orders made gross margin hard to follow mid-project. So they tracked gross margin per project as close to real time as they could: foremen entered crew hours from the field, purchase orders were coded to jobs, and project costs were reviewed in a monthly meeting. President Timothee Sallin told the magazine net profit rose by more than five points since they adopted the number about two years earlier.1
360 Lawn Care in Rock Hill, South Carolina, had 12 employees and a payroll problem. Owner Brandon Guffey: "Last year we did $320,000, and we spent $318,000."1 The article put 2014 payroll at 67 percent. He raised bids, gave crews budgeted hours for each job and had a supervisor fuel the trucks instead of the whole crew. The article said payroll was down to around 30 percent, and Guffey expected net profit near 10 percent, up from half a percent. His tool was a spreadsheet.1
Taylor Irrigation in Houston tracked client credits, which they call lessons learned, in a spreadsheet with 10 extra details per credit, like the truck, the day of the week, the division and the manager. Managers reviewed them weekly and used the trends for training. The article says credits typically run around 1 percent of revenue.1
Hours nobody could put on a job
TruCo Services is a Utah commercial landscaping and snow company. Its story comes from Aspire, the software company it moved to, so it's vendor marketing, and the page carries no date.2
Controller Kale Stevenson told the vendor that under their old setup they had 3,000 to 5,000 hours a month of unallocated time: labor that never landed on a job.2 Snow work was billed by the size of the storm, not the hours it took, so bids were off.
Once every hour was tied to a property, a crew and a service, they priced new bids from past similar jobs and used the history to justify renewal increases. Aspire's story says one contract went up 80%. Operations manager Nial Magoffin said starting spring cleanup in March added an extra couple weeks of work.2 The story doesn't say how many unassigned hours were left afterward.
Where the leads come from (a roofer)
Hail or High Water Roofing and Restoration in Lawrenceville, Georgia, opened in 2019. In an undated customer story from AccuLynx, its software vendor, the story says owner Steve Sims couldn't pull the reports he needed from his earlier software.3
The fix was simple: record the source of every lead, then compare cost per lead and close rate by channel. They also gave the sales team checklists. Sims told the vendor year over year sales rose 40%, and the page says the company saved tens of thousands of dollars on marketing, with no breakdown.3 Checklists, new software and lead tracking all landed together, so it's hard to say which did what.
Routes (pest control)
Cowleys Pest Services is a family company in New Jersey with over 33,000 customers and 6,400 monthly jobs. The story is WorkWave marketing, reposted on casestudies.com, and we couldn't read the original.4 They replaced a paper schedule book with digital scheduling and automated routing. The story claims 30 to 60 minutes less driving per tech each day and 20 to 25 more appointments per tech per day, with no one named and no before figures.4 Treat it as a direction, not a benchmark.
A note on cleaning
The only cleaning example we found is thin. A MaidCentral page about Natural Care Cleaning, Chad Henley's company, says direct labor costs fell from 50% to 40% while average wages rose from $15 per hour to nearly $20 per hour.5 There's no date, location or time frame, so read it as a vendor's summary. It's the same labor-share number 360 Lawn Care chased.
Two of the fictional companies in our demo, both built on synthetic data, ask questions in this family. Cedar & Stone, a commercial cleaner, asks "How many of our contracts use more crew hours than they pay for?" Alderwick, a restoration firm, asks which finished mitigation files are still waiting on an invoice, and what's holding them up.
Lessons
- Pick the number that matches your biggest leak. Margin per job, payroll share, credits, cost per lead. One is enough to start.
- Make every hour land somewhere. Unassigned hours and budgets per job are the same idea from two directions.
- Split by source or crew. Close rate by channel told the roofer where to spend.
- Put it on the calendar. LegacyScapes reviewed costs monthly and Taylor Irrigation reviewed credits weekly.
- Take vendor figures with a little salt. They roll software, process and price changes into one number.
For plumbing and HVAC versions of these lessons, see what plumbing and HVAC shops learned from their own numbers. If unbilled work is your leak, start with finished work that never got invoiced.
Sources
- Landscape Management, "Keeping score" (Dec. 2, 2015; updated Nov. 3, 2023). Trade press. landscapemanagement.net
- Aspire blog, "How TruCo Services used real-time job costing to build competitive bids, improve profit margins" (undated). Vendor marketing. youraspire.com
- AccuLynx, "How Hail or High Water Roofing grew sales and increased efficiency with AccuLynx" (undated). Vendor marketing. acculynx.com
- casestudies.com, "Case Study: Cowleys Pest Services boosts efficiency and growth with WorkWave PestPac" (reposted WorkWave story, undated). Vendor marketing. casestudies.com
- MaidCentral, Natural Care Cleaning success story (undated). Vendor marketing. maidcentral.com
What would you ask your own records?
Send us the one question you can't answer today, in your own words. We'll talk through whether the records you already keep can answer it. The Tiber River Business Data Platform is accepting design partners, and you can click around the live demo with a fictional company first.
Email Josh your questionOr write to josh@tiberriverconsulting.com