Small business blog · October 29, 2026

Are your maintenance agreements priced for the work they take?

A big stack of maintenance agreements feels like the safest money in the business. Whether each one actually pays for the visits it promises is a separate question, and the answer can change every year your costs go up.

For a lot of HVAC and plumbing shops, the agreement count is a point of pride. Members renew, they call you first, and the visits fill slow weeks. But an agreement is also a promise to show up a set number of times at a price you picked a while ago, and nobody sends you a bill when that price stops covering the work.

The "we make it up later" habit

Ruth King, who has more than 25 years in the HVACR industry working with contractors, distributors and manufacturers, wrote in HVACR Business in 2022 that contractors often have the misconception that they can lose money on maintenance because they make it up in service or replacement work. Her view is that everything you sell should at least break even.2

Her math shows why. In her example, a company with 1,000 agreements finds it's losing $10 on each one, or $10,000 total. At a 5% net profit, it would need to generate $200,000 in other work just to cover that.2 She also points out that a growing program hides the problem: as long as you keep selling agreements, cash keeps coming in. When growth stops, the losses start showing up as cash trouble.2

An earlier column of hers, from 2018, takes apart a competitor's $99 agreement that promised four visits a year. Using her own assumptions (four hours of total time including travel, a tech cost of $20 an hour including payroll taxes, workers comp and paid time off, $35 an hour of overhead, and a $10 spiff), she put the cost at $230 against $99 of revenue, a loss of $131 per agreement. At a 10% net profit, she figured revenue from that customer would have to be $1,310 a year to make up the loss, which she called not likely.1

How owners build the price

Butch Welsch, owner of Welsch Heating & Cooling in St. Louis, has described his approach in ACHR News more than once. In a 2015 column, he said his company set agreement pricing to at least break even. They figured 45 minutes per piece of furnace or air conditioning equipment and an average of 15 minutes per drive, and put the time for one furnace and one air conditioner a year at two hours. Then they added overhead and a minimal profit.3 The price had to stand on its own, he wrote, not depend on selling something during the call. His summary: "you are not trying to make a killing with your maintenance agreements."3

In 2021 he laid out the same build in steps: your average tech's time to maintain one unit, plus average travel between calls, doubled for two visits a year, times your hourly rate including overhead and profit. Add any spiff you pay. Add time for special conditions that make a visit run long.4

Notice what that method depends on. Real visit times. Real drive times. A real loaded hourly cost. King adds a wrinkle: if you price on the hourly cost of the techs who usually run maintenance and a higher paid tech takes the call, that ticket loses money. She suggests building in a minimum of $5 net profit per hour on residential agreements so there's some room for that.2

Prices drift, costs don't wait

Patrick Lange, an HVAC business broker who has owned an HVAC company, warned in a 2025 ACHR News guest column about companies signing customers to three or five year agreements at a couple of hundred dollars a year. Labor, fuel, vehicle upkeep and office scheduling costs don't stay the same, and he wrote that if inflation drives your costs up, you may end up breaking even or losing money on each call. He recommends a yearly pricing analysis and notes that a multi-year agreement can't be repriced until it ends.5

Owners who looked closely

Vassar Service of Richmond, in Mechanicsville, Virginia, moved from traditional agreements to what it calls high-performance agreements, testing equipment before and after the work. ACHR News reported in 2023 that the price went from $60-$80 to around $225. President and owner Cliff Dennis said they dug into their numbers to figure out what that level of service would take. "Previously, we weren't collecting enough data," he said. He told the magazine most customers pick the upgraded option when they see it next to the basic one.6

The same article reported that DiFilippo Service Co. in Paoli, Pennsylvania, keeps approximately 1,600 agreements with an annual renewal rate of 83%, according to president and owner Vince DiFilippo.6 Renewal rate is the other half of the picture. A well priced plan that doesn't renew won't help much either.

A check you can run on last year's agreements

A first answer takes a few exports and an afternoon.

  1. Your agreement list. Every active agreement with its plan, price, start date, term and number of included visits. Flag any multi-year agreements and anything that hasn't had a price change in a few years.
  2. Your visits. From your scheduling or dispatch software, every maintenance visit last year with the tech, time on site and drive time. If drive time isn't recorded, use clock in and clock out between calls.
  3. Your loaded hourly cost. From payroll, each tech's hourly cost with taxes and benefits. From your accounting reports, overhead per billable hour. If you pay a spiff on sales or renewals, add that too.
  4. Put them together by plan. For each plan, total the visit hours, multiply by loaded cost, add parts the plan covers, and set that next to what the plan brought in. Then sort individual agreements by loss and see what the worst ones share: a big house, a far zip code, an old system, a slower tech.
  5. Look at renewals by plan. If the cheap plan renews well and loses money, and the better plan pays but doesn't renew, that tells you where to start.

Pull-through counts, but count it honestly. If you believe a plan earns its keep through repairs and replacements, measure that by plan too: the work members bought in the year, not what you hope they'll buy.

Bringing the agreement list, the visit log and payroll together is the hard part, because they live in different systems. That's the kind of question the Tiber River Business Data Platform is built to answer, and you can see it asked on a fictional heating and plumbing company in the demo: which memberships cost more to service than they pay. For the same idea applied to whole jobs, read job costing against the estimate.

Sources

  1. HVACR Business, Ruth King, "The $99 Maintenance Agreement Too Good to be True" (2018, date per page URL). Trade press. hvacrbusiness.com
  2. HVACR Business, Ruth King, "Pricing Maintenance Agreements: Know Your Profit Bottomline" (2022, date per page URL). Trade press. hvacrbusiness.com
  3. ACHR News, Butch Welsch, "My Two Cents: The Evolution of Our Maintenance Agreement Program" (January 12, 2015). Trade press. achrnews.com
  4. ACHR News, Butch Welsch, "How to Use Maintenance Agreements to Keep the Revenue Flowing" (August 6, 2021). Trade press. achrnews.com
  5. ACHR News, Patrick Lange, "Think Maintenance Agreements Are Always a Win? Think Again." (guest column, September 6, 2025). Trade press. achrnews.com
  6. ACHR News, Herb Woerpel, "Contractors Share Maintenance Agreement Best Practices" (July 18, 2023). Trade press. achrnews.com

What would you ask your own records?

Send us the one question you can't answer today, in your own words. We'll talk through whether the records you already keep can answer it. The Tiber River Business Data Platform is accepting design partners, and you can click around the live demo with a fictional company first.

Email Josh your question

Or write to josh@tiberriverconsulting.com

← All small business posts