Job costing has a reputation as an accounting chore. Codes get entered, reports get printed, and the bids stay the same. It starts paying when somebody asks one plain question every month: on the jobs we just finished, where did we come in over what we bid, and what are we changing on the next one?
Enhanced Electrical, a shop in Reno and Sparks, Nevada, is a good example. In an undated customer story published by Simpro, the software they bought, co-owner Rebecca Baffrey said looking at original estimated hours against actual hours changed how they bid.1 Cory Byron, who owns Vancity Electric, told Jobber, the software company that published his story in 2026, that gross margin went from 20% to 50% and that job costing was a huge part of it.2 Both are vendor stories, so take the numbers as the owners' own accounts. The habit behind them is what's worth copying.
What to compare
Three comparisons cover most of what goes wrong on a job.
- Labor hours, by job type. Don't stop at the job total. Group by the kind of work your estimates already use: panel upgrades, service calls, tenant fit-outs, residential rough-in. One job running long is noise. Every panel upgrade running three hours long is a pricing problem.
- Materials. Compare what you estimated with what you bought for the job, then with what you billed. That last step catches material that got used and never made it onto an invoice, which was one of Enhanced Electrical's problems.1
- Change work. Track extra work apart from base scope, and check whether each piece was written up, signed and billed. Back in 2011, EC&M gave a general estimate that change-order work can cost 10% to 15% more than the same work in the original bid. The same article described one contractor whose change orders totaling more than $140,000 went unpaid, because the GC's project manager who approved them wasn't the authorized signer.3
Where those numbers usually live
In most shops the numbers already exist. They're just in four different places.
- The estimate sits in your estimating software, a takeoff program or a spreadsheet template. You want estimated hours and material for each job, broken out the same way you plan to compare them.
- Actual hours live in timesheets, a time-tracking app or payroll. Payroll is often the most complete, since everybody gets paid, but it only helps if hours are coded to a job.
- Actual materials are on supplier invoices and purchase orders. They're much easier to use when every order carries a job name or number.
- What you billed and collected is in your accounting software. QuickBooks' job or project profitability reports, or the equivalent in whatever you use, are a fine place to start.
The hard part is usually matching. A job gets one name on the estimate, another on the timesheet and a third on the supplier invoice. One job number used everywhere fixes more than any report will.
A monthly routine an owner can run
Once it's set up, this is an hour or two a month. Pick a day and stick to it.
- List last month's closed jobs. Finished jobs only. Open ones will just muddy the picture.
- Put estimate and actual side by side for hours and materials. A spreadsheet with one row per job is plenty.
- Group by job type and look at the typical gap for each. If a type only had a job or two this month, carry it into next month's look.
- Check change work. For every job with extras, was the work written up, signed and on the invoice?
- Pick one or two changes. Raise the labor allowance on the job type that keeps running long. Add a line to the estimating template for the material that keeps getting missed. Write down what you changed and why.
- Look again in three months. Did the gap on that job type close? If it didn't, the problem may be in the field rather than the bid.
Hours alone only tell you so much. If crews log time to a cost code but not how much they installed, you'll see that a job ran long without seeing why. Recording units installed per labor hour, even roughly, makes the comparison far more useful.
How common is this gap?
Good current numbers are hard to come by. The best survey we found is old: a 2012 FMI productivity survey, reported in EC&M. Among the electrical contractors who answered, 43% said their job cost reporting tracks units per labor hour, while nearly 60% recorded only time to a cost code. And 90% believed they could save at least 5% of yearly field labor cost through better management, while 67% reported overruns on at least 11% of projects.4
Two big caveats. The data is more than a decade old, and electrical contractors were only 12% of all responses, a sample the article says it can't claim represents electrical contractors in general. So read it as a sign this problem has been around a long time. It can't tell you where your own shop stands. Your last few months of jobs can.
Where to start
Take last month's closed jobs and do steps one and two by hand, even if it's ugly. You'll learn fast which numbers you have and which you're missing, and that's useful on its own.
If job costing looks fine but invoices lag, read finished work that never got invoiced. For a wider list of checks, see questions an electrical contractor's records can answer, or the roundup of what other electrical shops found.
Sources
- Simpro, "Enhanced Electrical" customer case study (undated). Vendor marketing. cdn.featuredcustomers.com
- Jobber, "How Vancity Electric Built a $1.4M Electrical Business and Hit 50% Margins with Jobber" (March 31, 2026). Vendor marketing. getjobber.com
- EC&M, Beck Ireland, "Taking Orders" (October 21, 2011). Trade press. ecmweb.com
- EC&M, Scott Kimpland of FMI, "Electrical Contractor Productivity Examined" (June 22, 2012). Trade press. ecmweb.com
What would you ask your own records?
Send us the one question you can't answer today, in your own words. We'll talk through whether the records you already keep can answer it. The Tiber River Business Data Platform is accepting design partners, and you can click around the live demo with a fictional company first.
Email Josh your questionOr write to josh@tiberriverconsulting.com