Ask most owners where their work comes from and you'll get a confident answer. Ask which source brings in the jobs that make money and the answer usually gets slower. That's because the two numbers live in different places. The lead is in the phone log or the scheduling software. The profit shows up weeks later in the job cost or the accounting reports. Unless someone ties them together, the busiest channel tends to look like the best one.
Count the leads you lost, too
Amy Cracco, who manages the office for Modern Yankee Builders, a residential remodeling company in Cumberland, Rhode Island, described their system in the Journal of Light Construction back in 2007. Whoever took the first call filled out a lead sheet, and once a quarter she typed the sheets into a spreadsheet that drew graphs. The key detail: they recorded the source for jobs they didn't get as well as the ones they did.2
Referrals got their own codes depending on who sent them (friends and family, an architect, a trade sub, a current or past client, a repeat client), plus the referrer's name. They also graded finished projects on whether they were profitable, good looking, both or neither.2
What came out was useful. They signed one construction contract for every three to four leads, a ratio that held over time, so they could tell whether they had enough leads in the pipe. Job site signs, newsletters, mailings and the website brought some leads but rarely turned into paid work. Friends and family referrals were the most likely to reach construction.2
Architects sent a lot of leads that didn't become construction contracts, which at first glance made them look like a weak source. But a high share of those leads had been classified as potential clients. Cracco read that as a sign the problem might be their own sales approach, not the source.2 That's the kind of thing a single close rate hides.
When the busy channel isn't the good one
In 1999, Pro Remodeler profiled Mike Miller of Apex Construction Remodeling in Highland, Indiana. He started tracking leads when he noticed that print advertising brought plenty of inquiries that weren't turning into jobs. "I was shooting arrows all over the place, not at the target," he told the magazine. The tracking showed his core business was existing clients and referrals, and he used a newsletter to keep the company in front of them.3
The same pattern shows up in HVAC advice. Blaine Fox, then a vice president at Warm Thoughts Communications and formerly general manager of ServiceMark, a $32 million HVAC contractor, wrote in Contracting Business in 2009 that owners should track close rates and average job price by lead source, because different sources produce different results on both. He pointed to survey data showing referrals closing at a much higher rate than Yellow Pages leads, and Internet leads bringing a higher average job price than coupon clippers.1
Close rate is only half of it
A source can close well and still lose money if the jobs are small or the leads are expensive. Theo Prada, founder of a marketing agency that works with home service contractors, made that point in a 2026 column for Contractor magazine. His example: if HVAC leads cost $70 and you close one in three, you're paying about $210 to book a job. That barely matters on a $6,000 system replacement and matters a lot on a $150 service call.5 He describes his ranges as directional, drawn from the accounts his agency manages and widely reported figures, so treat them as one agency's view.
Alan Hanbury, writing in Pro Remodeler in 2004, pushed the cost side further. He counted the cost per contract signed as all sales and marketing spending divided by contracts, and he included the wages of the owner, office staff and salespeople. His own firm's figure was $580 with wages and $220 without. If that cost runs high against your average job size, he wrote, it might exceed the gross profit on those jobs, which raises the question of whether you should be doing that kind of work at all.6
Where the tracking goes wrong
The source field is only as good as whoever fills it in. Fox recommended 8 to 12 simple categories rather than 25 or 30, a clear rule for who counts as a current customer, and an objective person keeping the log instead of the salespeople tracking their own close rates.1
Attribution is messy too. In a 2017 ACHR News article, Todd Bairstow of Keyword Connects recommended a dedicated phone number for every marketing source, and tracking web forms the same way. Ed Cerier of Nexstar Network warned that a TV ad might build the awareness while the call shows up as coming from Google, and that a stack of postcards can earn a call that only one of them gets credit for.4 So read source numbers as strong hints, not verdicts.
A check you can run on last year's leads
- Every lead, not just the wins. Export last year's leads or estimates with the date, source and outcome. If source is blank on a lot of them, that's your first finding.
- Jobs with money attached. From your scheduling or job software, every completed job with its invoice total. From your job costing or accounting reports, labor and materials per job, so you can get gross profit, not just revenue.
- Spend by source. Ad invoices, lead service bills and agency fees, grouped into the same categories.
- Put them side by side. For each source: leads, jobs won, close rate, average job, gross profit per job, and spend per job won. Then sort by gross profit per dollar spent, not by lead count.
- Look twice at the low closers. Before you cut a source, check whether the leads were good and the follow up wasn't, the way Cracco did with her architect leads.
Repeat customers count as a source. If past clients and referrals close best, as Miller found, the money you spend staying in touch with them belongs in this table too.
The hard part is joining the lead log to the job records and the spending, because they rarely live in one system. The Tiber River Business Data Platform is built for that kind of question, and you can see it asked on a fictional flooring company in the demo: what installed jobs made, by lead source. For the job side of the math, read job costing against the estimate.
Sources
- Contracting Business, Blaine Fox, "HVAC Contractors' New Year's Resolution" (Dec. 30, 2009). Trade press. contractingbusiness.com
- Journal of Light Construction, Amy Cracco, "Looking Back at Job Leads" (November 1, 2007). Trade press. jlconline.com
- Pro Remodeler, "Lead Tracking" (May 1, 1999). Trade press. proremodeler.com
- ACHR News, Nicole Krawcke, "Measuring Marketing the Key to HVAC Contracting Success" (February 20, 2017). Trade press. achrnews.com
- Contractor, Theo Prada, "Mastering Lead Cost Benchmarks for Plumbing & HVAC Success" (column by a marketing agency founder, Aug. 4, 2026). Trade press. contractormag.com
- Pro Remodeler, Alan Hanbury, "Leading the Way to Profit" (Sept. 1, 2004). Trade press. proremodeler.com
What would you ask your own records?
Send us the one question you can't answer today, in your own words. We'll talk through whether the records you already keep can answer it. The Tiber River Business Data Platform is accepting design partners, and you can click around the live demo with a fictional company first.
Email Josh your questionOr write to josh@tiberriverconsulting.com