Small business blog · October 8, 2026

How small contractors and subs put their own numbers to work

A remodeler's own account, plus the better vendor stories from subs and GCs, read with a fair amount of skepticism. The habits underneath are the part worth copying.

Most data success stories online were published by the company that sold the software. That doesn't make them false, but you should read them knowing who wrote them. So we'll start with a contractor telling it in his own words, then the more useful vendor stories, then what a 10 to 100 person sub or GC can copy.

A remodeler who closes the loop on finished jobs

Jim Kabel owns Next Stage Design + Build, a design-build remodeler in San Jose, California. In a 2024 article he wrote for Pro Remodeler, he laid out how the company handles job costing on fixed-price contracts, which he says his state requires.1

The pieces are ordinary. Estimates come from templates for kitchens, baths and additions, and the estimate categories line up with the cost accounts in the books. In-house labor is split into buckets like demo, rough carpentry and finish carpentry, so hours can be checked against the estimate bucket by bucket. Field staff log time on simple mobile tools. Only direct, billable items count as job cost.

Then comes the part most shops skip. Project developers are paid based on estimated and actual gross profit, and field crews share a bonus tied to the labor estimate. Finished jobs get a final review with finance, production, design and sales. Kabel describes it as non-punitive, and the action items can include changes to the estimating data.

His result, in his words: the company has been "maintaining a job cost variance of plus or minus 1%" for the last several years.1 That's self-reported, with no audit and no before number. It's still the clearest picture we found of the habit itself.

A yardstick for remodelers. NAHB's Remodelers' Cost of Doing Business Study, posted in April 2026, put the average remodeler's gross margin at 29.9% for fiscal 2024 and net margin at 6.3%, the highest since 1996. NAHB named lower trade contractor costs, down from 36% of revenue in 2021 to 30%, as the main driver.2 If you remodel, it's a fair line to hold your own close-out numbers against.

Knowing which bids you win

Bowman Flooring Contractor in Acworth, Georgia, sets commercial tile, mostly in fast-casual and quick-service restaurants. According to a customer case study published by BuildingConnected, the Autodesk bid software the company adopted, bids used to run through email and Excel, with no way to track wins and losses or tell which projects were worth bidding.3

After moving every bid into one tracked system, with past estimates and win rates by general contractor in view, senior project manager Mike Adams said "we've increased our win rate by 25%."3 He also said the company was $9 million over the prior year. Read that with some care. The case study doesn't say whether 25% is relative or in percentage points, and the gain bundles a new tool with a new process.

The underlying habit costs very little. SMACNews, the sheet metal contractors' association magazine, wrote in 2021 that 65% of specialty contractors aren't actively tracking their hit rate, though the article didn't cite a study for the figure.4 A spreadsheet with one row per bid, showing the GC, the job type, the amount and whether you won, starts telling you things within a season.

Change tickets that stop disappearing

Tore Electric in Dover, New Jersey, has been in business since 1960. In a customer story published by Clearstory, the change-order software it moved to, the company described paper T&M tags hand-carried in and dropped in a basket. It said it was losing about ten a month, and reconciling tags took weeks.5 With electronic tags, the story says, tags no longer go missing and the office saves more than eight hours a week. Sheryl Minerly told Clearstory that turning a tag into a change order used to take at least a week, and now happens the day the tag is written.5

Closer to home, Battaglia Electric in New Castle, Delaware, moved its change-order requests off paper with the same vendor. Senior project manager Scott Hibbard reported a big drop in revenue leakage, though that story gives no dollar figure.6

A ticket that isn't written, signed and logged the day of the work is money at risk, whatever software you use. More on that in finished work that never gets invoiced.

Connecting purchasing, projects and the books

Green Mechanical Construction, a mechanical contractor in Glasgow, Kentucky, was running on Excel, email and paper. In a customer story published by Procore, the project software it adopted, the company tied purchase orders to its accounting system and to job costs. The story says processing a PO went from 32 minutes to 7, and the cost per order from $18.23 to $4.73. Across more than 2,000 POs a year, Procore's story puts that at over $30,000 a year.7

Gideon Construction, a general contractor in Valdosta, Georgia, tells a similar story from the accounting side, in a case study published by Foundation Software, its accounting vendor. CFO Amanda Nobles said the time spent keying data between the project and accounting systems dropped from a couple of hours to 30 minutes.8

These are the most vendor-shaped stories here, and the dollar math is the vendor's. What's worth noticing is the plumbing these stories rely on: a purchase order that carries a job number, and a job number that means the same thing in every system.

What a 10 to 100 person sub or GC can take from this

Sources

  1. Pro Remodeler, Jim Kabel of Next Stage Design + Build, "6 Strategies to Optimize Gross Profit" (July 24, 2024). Trade press. proremodeler.com
  2. NAHB, Eye On Housing, Rose Quint, "Remodelers Saw Profit Margin Gains in 2024" (April 8, 2026). Association. eyeonhousing.org
  3. Autodesk BuildingConnected, "How Bowman Flooring Increased Win Rates by 25% with Cloud-based Bid Management" (undated; file created November 2023). Vendor marketing. a.storyblok.com
  4. SMACNA, SMACNews, "The Bidding Hack: 5 Ways to Increase Your Bid Win Rate" (April 30, 2021). Association. smacna.org
  5. Clearstory, "How Tore Electric Saves 8 Hours per Week on Change Orders" (undated). Vendor marketing. clearstory.build
  6. Clearstory, Battaglia Electric customer story, "Streamlining the Change Order Process with Clearstory" (undated). Vendor marketing. clearstory.build
  7. Procore, Green Mechanical Construction customer story (undated). Vendor marketing. procore.com
  8. Foundation Software, "How a General Contractor Scaled Operations and Simplified Accounting with FOUNDATION" (Gideon Construction, undated). Vendor marketing. foundationsoft.com

What would you ask your own records?

Send us the one question you can't answer today, in your own words. We'll talk through whether the records you already keep can answer it. The Tiber River Business Data Platform is accepting design partners, and you can click around the live demo with a fictional company first.

Email Josh your question

Or write to josh@tiberriverconsulting.com

← All small business posts